This latest volume in the Penal Theory and Penal Ethics series addresses one of the oldest and most contested questions in the field of criminal sentencing: should an offender's previous convictions affect the sentence? This question provokes a series of others: Is it possible to justify a discount for first offenders within a retributive sentencing framework? How should previous convictions enter into the sentencing equation? At what point should prior misconduct cease to count for the purposes of fresh sentencing? Should similar previous convictions count more than convictions unrelated to the current offence? Statutory sentencing regimes around the world incorporate provisions which mandate harsher treatment of repeat offenders. Although there is an extensive literature on the definition and use of criminal history information, the emphasis here, as befits a volume in the series, is on the theoretical and normative aspects of considering previous convictions at sentencing. Several authors explore the theory underlying the practice of mitigating the punishments for first offenders, while others put forth arguments for enhancing sentences for recidivists. The practice of sentencing repeat offenders in two jurisdictions (England and Wales, and Sweden) is also examined in detail.

1 Proportionality and the Progressive Loss of Mitigation: Some Further Reflections Andrew von Hirsch2 First-Offender Sentencing Discounts: Exploring the Justifications Julian V Roberts3 Recidivism, Retributivism, and the Lapse Theory of Previous Convictions Jesper Ryberg4 Repeat Offenders and the Question of Desert Youngjae Lee5 'More to Apologise For': Can We Find a Basis for the Recidivist Premium in a Communicative Theory of Punishment? Chris Bennett6 The Questionable Relevance of Previous Convictions to Punishments for Later Crimes Michael Tonry7 Prior-conviction Sentencing Enhancements: Rationales and Limits Based on Retributive and Utilitarian Proportionality Principles and Social Equality Goals Richard S Frase8 The Illusion of Proportionality: Desert and Repeat Offenders Kevin R Reitz9 Dimensions of Criminal History: Reflections on Theory and Practice Martin Wasik10 The Role of Previous Convictions in England and Wales Estella Baker and Andrew Ashworthx Contents11 Previous Convictions and Proportionate Punishment under Swedish Law Petter Asp12 Assessing the Impact of a Recidivist Sentencing Premium on Crime and Recidivism Rates Lila KazemianIndex